For The Record...
"In an interview with Yahoo! Singapore, Zainudin (Nordin, FAS President) reiterated that the S-league will not become a "poorer cousin" once the LionsXII start their Malaysia Cup campaign."

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

Guest Opinion - Refereeing Woes : What Rugby can teach its cousin a thing or two on how to resolve it...

(P.S: This entry will kick start a new column in this blog with readers are welcome to submit their article on various issues pertaining to local football scene as "guest columnist")

Mr Paul Kung, someone who has been very active in the rugby community as a player, coach and administrator shares his thoughts with us, from the rugby perspective, after he read some of the recent blog entries regarding the man-in-the-middle.

I have read that there is some debate in football about how much 'power' the Assistant referees have. I know that in the BPL and other professional leagues they are all miked up with communications equipment - "walkie talkies" so that all three referees can speak to each other and flag up any infractions.

The model most commonly used here is T5500 (above) and is fairly inexpensive - about $150 for a set if I remember correctly. They are powered by normal batteries as well.

As far as I know, this radio and throat vibration set (above) is used in the army as well and works rather well.

In Rugby (Union) particularly, the Assistant referees have recently been given more power to help the man in the middle manage the game. They can tell the ref of infringements of any kind.

In Singapore - local rugby referees for the big games (finals and Premier league games) actually use a communication system. This is not expensive - regular "Motorola" walkie talkies with earpieces and mikes which gives all three referees communication with each other.

These are the same radios that I used in my school coaching, and is still in use now by a lot of school's sports teams to communicate between coaches.

(Picture credit: Static.guim.co.uk) A referee with this comms equipment is a common feature in European Leagues.
I wonder if this could be done in Singapore - for then S.League - this is already being done for the BPL - why not the S.League? The technology is not that expensive , and as other sports have shown, while not as good as the expensive equipment, just as serviceable and good.

I personally think that this would help all three referees on the field look out for each other.

Another thing - and this might be more of a personal thing - but it always seems that the most arguments and on field displays of disagreement with the referee occurs most in football.
Look at all codes of rugby - Rugby League, Union and even AFL (Aussie Rules football) - there are fewer instances where players argue with the referee after a call is made. Most professional players will walk away and keep quiet. Even at basketball, you do get the occasional confrontation, but nothing major.

(Picture credit: ABC- The Sports Desk) In Rugby, there are fewer instances where players argue with the ref after a call is made, why?
Is on field behaviour towards refs the issue? Does football players let passion get the best of them?

One would think that being professional S.League players will bring some form of professionalism. That being said, all one has to do is look at how the game is paid at the top level in England and Europe and you will know that that is not the case - a sport specific culture thing?

Many thanks to Mr Kung for his opinions on this much-debated issue, let's sincerely hope his views would eventually pick up the league authority soon.

8 comments:

  1. So if i have the same walkie talkie, can i listen to the referees' conversation?

    ReplyDelete
  2. You would need to know the channel they are on, which would mean screening each frequency, and there are a multiple number of combinations.

    Also,the coms equipment would be used only for infractions, so it would be a continuous chat - so quite boring!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This have been debated. This kind of walkie talkie pohui tok abt cannot used in soocer cos fifa say all the conversations can only be heard and used by referees only. nobody shud hear or record their conversation to prevent controversies.
    So the right walkie talkie used in most soccer games like bpL, serie A is nt those cheapo $150 motorola. Its kind of a 4 set of walkie talkie for each refs with a unique channel nobody cud enter.
    Shamsul maidin have roamed all over the world but cud nt find a cheap one. most to most US$50k per set. And hw bout maintenance in case it spoilt??

    Look at this example on walkie-talkie used by uefa featuring norwegian ref Tom Ovrebo: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzRlwsWRyvs

    Sleague will never afford these.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi all 3 "Anonymous"...

    Thanks for the feedback.

    Personally, I felt rugger in this aspect is more "open" as compared to football in a way that on televised match I saw, viewers actually get to listen to what the referee said (though ONLY the referee as nothing would be heard from his assistant - the video referee.

    Also years ago, I watched a program that was showing the highlights on South American football and I did recall a soundman actually placed the "mike" in between the referee and the linesman who were discussing a foul.

    I think it's a matter of whether we are gonna accept this kinda "openness" in our game.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I personally thk the sponsors of refs pay for these things(i nt so sure).

    EPL ref got local umbro, airasia, lucozade sport, polar heart rate monitor, prozone.

    serie a got local diadora, sixtus.

    bundesliga ref got local DEKRA, ERA real estate poperty agency.

    La Liga got wurth elektronik.

    ANd this sponsors nt only provide refs kit but also finance their training but nt sure if they sponsor the walkie-talkie.

    sleague ref got local brand vonda last time.
    i really hope when sleague is popular, some local company can come in & sponsor our ref.

    ReplyDelete
  6. How about setting up a 3 way conference call using mobile phone?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Somemore AFC champs league oso no walkie-talkie.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi "Anonymous"(who posted on 20/8 at 1127hrs)...

    My opinion is that if you're at a stadium where the mobile phone network coverage is poor, the communication between the referees might be an issue.

    ReplyDelete

"While I allow comment/feedback to be posted using the moniker "Anonymous" but comments containing discrimination of race, derogatory terms and seditious remarks will NOT be tolerated and will be deleted, if necessary, at the blog owner's discretion!

Please don't abuse it, thanks

And the blog owner WILL not be responsible for comments by visitors except those of his own

All comments are subjected to moderation and publish upon determination, thanks

Thank You for your kind attention"
Pohui

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails